“Look at every path closely and deliberately, then ask ourselves this crucial question: Does this path have a heart? If it does, then the path is good. If it doesn't, it is of no use.”
~Carlos Castaneda

Pages

Tuesday, February 6, 2007

The residents and medical students now adays are soft .....

5am this morning .... I am out running ... 8 mile run ... training ... marathon training ... it's been cold outside ... today, cold and a fresh coat of snow ... the numbers of runners are far fewer ... several people walking dogs ... very few footprints in the snow .... I run past a older man (grey mustache and hair) ... I've seen him before ... We are the dedicated few ... continuing our training regardless of the weather ... like the postal service .... rain or shine, we will be there .... we smile at each other with a kind of understanding not understood by those still in bed ....

I look at the young doctors coming into medicine now a days and their perception of what is expected of them and what they are willing to do is less. Will they run in a storm. Will they stay until all the work is done or will they say, " my shift is done" and leave.

Times are changing, but the patients are not. The amount of work that is needed to be done does not. Residency programs are now dealing with how do we adapt to the 80hr work week. It has become difficult for most programs to accommodate the restrictions. A number of things within residencies have changed to adapt to the changing hour restrictions. As programs become more accustom to working within the restrictions, so do the young physicians. They become more likely to schedule those hair appointments during the day (4:30pm or so) etc. The medical students leave without even checking out. I say strange. This is a definite change from when I was a medical student or resident. The expectation is different.

You may say, "Well, it is a different time and place. We don't need to do every other night call or stay in the hospital 2 days straight to be a good physician." And I would say, "You are exactly right." I do not think that you should spend countless hours in the hospital doing nothing. I would agree that more time spent reading and not doing busy work is probably better in the long haul. Andrew Palmer, MD, former president of the American society for Surgery of the Hand, made an opening address several years ago making a plea to many young physicians to find other interests outside of medicine. He felt that after many years dedicating his life to medicine, researching, operating, and teaching, he learned that there is a need to develop other interests. A need to develop yourself without medicine. So, I do feel that this is an important.

The problem we have now is the same problem that you get with unions. Yes, being formed is protective, but a certain mentality develops. The mentality developing now is that of a sense of entitlement. A sense that menial work is beneath them and that they should only do meaningful things. They don't need to prove themselves before we let them make decisions or make incisions.

Some may read this and say, "he is full of it. I am not like that." Well, not now, but there is a changing mentality. We had a visiting lecturer from the UK who gave us a lecture of the system in Britain. He was describing their work hour restrictions and how they have adapted. They are now down to, I think, 48 hrs a week. He says now they have more residents, to cover the time; the number of "hand off" errors have increased; and the operative case number is dropping. He reported to us when the restrictions began, the residents there said, "we will stay, regardless of the restrictions." Now, when time is up they just leave, regardless if they are in the middle of a case or in clinic, time is up and they are gone.

This mentality will creep slowly into the mentality of most as it has done in the auto industry. I fear the development of shift workers. I say that the medical students and residents are weak to incite anger in you. I want you to prove me wrong. Prove to me, yourself, that you have the fortitude to weather the storm, the cold, and the snow. Maybe one day when I am old and grey I will see you and we will smile together with an unspoken understanding.

3 comments:

  1. i was told the 48 hour rule in europe was enforced with very steep penalties for both residents and the programs. if i was going to be fined a 1000$ for being there an extra hour, of course id leave in the middle of a case.

    why should we have to prove ourselves with doing busywork when in the end practicing orthopods work 6-5 jobs with call once a week? ive already spent most of my twenties with a book in front of my face; i think most of us have already proven ourselves and ability to do seemingly pointless tasks (like memorize the krebs cycle). and lets not forget, when residents are overworked, patients die.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You probably need to accept the fact that times are changing. The sacrifices you made when you trained were made in the knowledge that when you became an attending you would have certain perks - high pay, not having lawsuits hanging over your head, not battling insurance companies to the death constantly. As a result, you were willing to make certain sacrifices.

    Our generation knows that we're not getting your deal and we're not even going to get the current situation. In 20 years we'll have socialized health care, shifts and salaries of 100k. In Germany all doctors work 32 hours a week and make 65k. Do I want to be the best physician I can? Yes. Does this involve sacrificing my entire life in training? No. Like the old saw about "How do you ask a man to be the last one to die in a war" goes, "how do you ask a resident to be the last sacrifice for a dying system".

    ReplyDelete
  3. How can anyone possibly be the best physician they can be without sacrificing some aspect of their life?

    No athlete who strives to be the best in the world will succeed if he doesn't sacrifice his life during training.

    ReplyDelete